5th Brooklyn just held its first camp of the season, at Clarence Fahnestock State Park, one of our favorites.

The Otters camped on one of the group sites, and our Northern Timberwolf Pack set up on individual sites about four miles away.  Our Pathfinder troop camped in a corner of our group site, and used their lashing skills to create a very cool obstacle course for our Otters to navigate.

Coming from the theater, I use a "Roses & Thorns" approach to post-mortems; it's important to recognize our victories at the same time that we find places where we could do better.  Positive and negative feedback are both important as we strive to better ourselves.  With that in mind, here are my first reactions to the past weekend:


  • One of our leaders made a wooden chore chart to help our Camp Patrols keep track of their assignments.  It was very cool, and helped set the tone.
  • We disseminated a schedule to the parents and posted a laminated version at the kitchen.  This was very helpful in keeping the weekend moving along.
  • We broke out activities on that schedule and recruited help for each of them, so parent volunteers 
  • We also sent the parents a list of camp chores they could help with, and worked to make sure that we didn't have a lot of adults standing around.
  • We tied our meeting activities in with camp activities (such as an introduction to Orienteering at the last meeting and more in-depth orienteering exercises at camp).
  • We held a parent "get to know you" meeting after campfire on the first night.  This was a great opportunity for new members to put names to faces, and for us to learn something new about people we've known for a while.


  • I don't think we did the best job setting expectations for some of the basics; we had a hard time getting the Otters to wash their own dishes, and hang them in the nets afterwards.  An "intro to camp" session (or document) would have helped.
  • We didn't have an official photographer, so in trying to recapture the fun we're now at the mercy of whatever the parents happened to catch.
  • We could have done more with the patrols.  We ended up not doing skits because our Sunday hike was more strenuous than planned, so one of the major patrol-bonding experiences ended up not happening.
  • On a personal level, I missed some of campfire on Sunday because I had to go to the Timberwolf camp for my scout.  I don't know that I could have done anything differently, but it was still very frustrating to not be with the Otters at such an important time.
  • Speaking on that Sunday hike, I set a trail for us that was much too ambitious.  I mis-remembered a previous hike, and had to adjust on the fly.  I've made notes in my camp journal about the trail that should make next year go much more smoothly.

More to come, this just my attempt to get initial reactions "on paper."

Views: 44

Comment by William Carter on October 12, 2016 at 1:15pm

Great analysis of what went well and what could be improved. 

Nat'l Staff
Comment by Joseph C. Braxton on October 23, 2016 at 8:58am

Sounds like you're on the right track. One suggestion might be to take the Pathfinders out on a "recon hike/camp" , getting photos and other ideas for the rest of the group for their next outing. That way, the Pathfinders get to do some "service" by "blazing" the path for their younger scout brothers and sisters. All in all it looks like you are "well on the trail".

Comment by M. Michele Brown on October 23, 2016 at 11:28am

It sounds like an amazing camp experience. I love the idea of Roses & Thorns by the way.


You need to be a member of Baden-Powell Service Association Trailhead to add comments!

Join Baden-Powell Service Association Trailhead

Welcome to the BPSA Base Camp

Networking site for BPSA members & staff, plus anyone else interested in growing our coed, inclusive, traditional scouting program in the United States.

Latest Activity

Nat'l Staff
Will Adamson added a discussion to the group South Region

SW Virginia BTC/Moot April 7-9, 2017

I just posted an event listing for a BTC/Moot to be held in Abingdon, VA April 7-9.  Cost will be $30.  Fee will cover badges awarded, Brownsea necker, food, and some instructional materials.  If you are a Rover Squire who wishes to pursue knighting…See More
21 hours ago

Nat'l Staff
Will Adamson posted an event

Southwest Virginia BTC 2017 at Abingdon Muster Grounds

April 7, 2017 at 6pm to April 9, 2017 at 12pm
BTC for those who need it, with concurrent Moot.See More
21 hours ago

Nat'l Staff
Scott Hudson posted a discussion

New Chipmunk Shirts in QM Store

I've added the first of Chipmunk specific items.Chipmunk ItemsSee More
William Carter replied to Celeste Neiser's discussion Scout Science Ideas for March for Science on Earth Day
"This book has some good ideas.  http://thedump.scoutscan.com/workingmodels.pdf Have fun!"

Nat'l Staff
Scott Hudson posted discussions
Jennifer Best joined David Atchley's group

Scout Groups & Leaders

A Group for current and prospective Scout Group Leaders and other warranted group positions (Group Scoutmaster, Troop Leaders, Pack Leaders, Otter Leaders, and assistants for each).See More
Jennifer Best updated their profile
Jennifer Best posted a group

28th South Mountain

We are a new group in Northern NJ.See More


  • Add Videos
  • View All




© 2017   Created by Jeffrey Kaye.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service